Request a Demo

    We’ll tailor your demo to your immediate needs and answer all your questions. Get ready to see how it works!

    Choosing the right shipping solution can make or break your small business. With rising customer expectations and tight profit margins, finding a cost-effective and reliable shipping partner is crucial. But should you stick with traditional shipping methods or embrace modern solutions like MyParcel?

    In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare MyParcel with traditional shipping providers to help you make the best decision for your small business in 2026.

    What is MyParcel?

    MyParcel is a modern shipping platform designed specifically for online businesses. It acts as a central hub that connects your eCommerce store with multiple carriers including PostNL, DHL, and DPD. Rather than managing relationships with multiple shipping companies, MyParcel provides a single, streamlined interface for all your shipping needs.

    The platform offers automated label generation, real-time tracking, and integrated returns management—all through one easy-to-use dashboard.

    What is Traditional Shipping?

    Traditional shipping refers to working directly with individual carriers like PostNL, DHL, UPS, or FedEx. This typically involves:

    • Creating separate accounts with each carrier
    • Using different platforms or software for each provider
    • Manually managing shipping labels and documentation
    • Negotiating rates individually with each carrier
    • Handling customer service through multiple channels

    Head-to-Head Comparison

    1. Cost Effectiveness

    MyParcel:

    • No setup fees: Get started without any upfront investment
    • Volume discounts: Automatically access better rates as you ship more
    • Transparent pricing: Clear cost breakdown with no hidden fees
    • Pay-as-you-go: Only pay for what you use, no monthly commitments
    • Bulk shipping rates: Benefit from MyParcel’s negotiated carrier rates

    Traditional Shipping:

    • Account fees: Many carriers charge monthly or annual fees
    • Minimum volumes: Often require minimum shipping volumes for good rates
    • Variable pricing: Rates can change without notice
    • Negotiation required: You need leverage to get competitive rates
    • Hidden costs: Fuel surcharges, residential delivery fees, and more

    Winner: MyParcel – Small businesses benefit from collective bargaining power and transparent pricing without minimum volume requirements.

    2. Time Investment

    MyParcel:

    • Single integration: Connect once to access multiple carriers
    • Automated workflows: Orders automatically sync from your store
    • Bulk processing: Generate hundreds of labels in minutes
    • One dashboard: Manage all shipments in one place
    • Quick setup: Get started in under 30 minutes

    Traditional Shipping:

    • Multiple integrations: Set up each carrier separately
    • Manual processes: Often requires manual data entry
    • Time-consuming: Switch between different platforms and systems
    • Complex setup: Each carrier has different requirements
    • Training needed: Staff must learn multiple systems

    Winner: MyParcel – Automation and centralization save hours of administrative work every week.

    3. Features and Functionality

    MyParcel:

    • ✅ Automated label generation
    • ✅ Real-time tracking across all carriers
    • ✅ Integrated returns portal
    • ✅ Branded tracking pages
    • ✅ Delivery time estimates
    • ✅ Multiple shipping options (standard, express, evening delivery)
    • ✅ International shipping support
    • ✅ API access for custom integrations
    • ✅ Mobile app for on-the-go management
    • ✅ Analytics and reporting dashboard

    Traditional Shipping:

    • ✅ Direct carrier relationship
    • ✅ Carrier-specific features
    • ❌ No unified tracking system
    • ❌ Limited automation options
    • ❌ Separate returns processes for each carrier
    • ❌ Inconsistent customer experience
    • ⚠️ Advanced features often cost extra
    • ⚠️ Limited reporting capabilities

    Winner: MyParcel – Modern features designed specifically for eCommerce businesses.

    4. Customer Experience

    MyParcel:

    • Consistent branding: Customize tracking pages with your logo and colors
    • Proactive notifications: Automated SMS and email updates
    • Easy returns: Customer-friendly return portal
    • Delivery options: Let customers choose their preferred delivery time
    • Real-time tracking: Live updates across all carriers

    Traditional Shipping:

    • Generic tracking: Customers redirected to carrier websites
    • Manual notifications: You need to send updates yourself
    • Complex returns: Different process for each carrier
    • Limited options: Dependent on individual carrier offerings
    • Inconsistent experience: Varies by carrier used

    Winner: MyParcel – Creates a professional, branded experience that builds customer trust.

    5. Scalability

    MyParcel:

    • Grows with your business automatically
    • No need to renegotiate contracts as you scale
    • Easy to add new carriers or shipping options
    • Volume discounts kick in automatically
    • Infrastructure handles high-volume periods (Black Friday, holidays)

    Traditional Shipping:

    • Must renegotiate rates as volumes change
    • May need to switch carriers for better rates
    • Scaling often requires new software or systems
    • Growing pains during high-volume periods
    • Additional staff needed to manage complexity

    Winner: MyParcel – Seamlessly scales from 10 to 10,000 shipments per month.

    Real-World Cost Comparison

    Let’s look at a practical example for a small business shipping 200 packages per month within the Netherlands:

    Cost FactorMyParcelTraditional Shipping
    Monthly Account Fee€0€25-50
    Average Cost per Parcel€5.95€7.50
    Shipping Software€0 (included)€29-99
    Returns Processing€0 (included)€15-30
    Time Saved (valued at €25/hr)~€200/month€0
    Total Monthly Cost€1,190€1,669-1,729
    Monthly Savings with MyParcel: €479-539 (~40% reduction)

    *Prices are estimates based on typical Dutch small business scenarios. Actual costs may vary.

    When Traditional Shipping Might Make Sense

    While MyParcel wins in most categories, traditional shipping might be better if:

    • You ship very high volumes: If you’re shipping 10,000+ packages per month, you might negotiate better direct rates
    • You use specialized services: Highly specialized shipping needs (hazardous materials, oversized freight) may require direct carrier relationships
    • You have existing contracts: If you’re locked into favorable long-term carrier contracts
    • You need specific carrier features: Some niche carrier services may not be available through MyParcel

    Success Story: How a Dutch Online Store Saved 35% on Shipping

    “Before MyParcel, we were spending 15 hours per week managing shipments across three different carriers. We were constantly switching between platforms, manually entering data, and fielding customer complaints about tracking. After switching to MyParcel, we cut our shipping costs by 35% and reduced our admin time to just 2 hours per week. The automated tracking notifications alone have reduced our customer service inquiries by 60%.”

    — Sarah de Vries, Owner of NatuurlijkMooi.nl

    Making the Switch: How to Transition from Traditional Shipping to MyParcel

    Ready to make the move? Here’s how to transition smoothly:

    Step 1: Sign Up (5 minutes)

    • Create your MyParcel account at myparcel.nl
    • No credit card required to get started
    • Verify your business information

    Step 2: Connect Your Store (15 minutes)

    • Integrate MyParcel with your eCommerce platform (Shopify, WooCommerce, Store.icu, etc.)
    • Configure your shipping rules and preferences
    • Set up your branded tracking page

    Step 3: Test Shipments (30 minutes)

    • Create a few test orders
    • Generate labels and verify tracking
    • Test the customer experience

    Step 4: Go Live (Immediate)

    • Start using MyParcel for all new orders
    • Phase out traditional shipping gradually
    • Monitor performance and adjust as needed

    Integration with Store.icu

    If you’re using Store.icu to power your eCommerce business, integrating MyParcel is incredibly simple. Store.icu’s white-label platform includes native MyParcel integration, allowing you to:

    • Automatically sync orders from your store to MyParcel
    • Generate shipping labels directly from your Store.icu dashboard
    • Provide customers with real-time tracking updates
    • Manage returns seamlessly
    • Access all MyParcel features without leaving your Store.icu admin panel

    Learn More About Store.icu + MyParcel →

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can I use MyParcel if I’m already working with carriers directly?

    Yes! MyParcel can work alongside your existing carrier relationships. Many businesses use MyParcel for domestic shipments while maintaining direct relationships for international or specialized shipping.

    What happens if MyParcel raises their prices?

    MyParcel’s pricing is transparent and competitive. Unlike traditional carriers, you’re not locked into long-term contracts, so you can always evaluate your options. However, MyParcel’s collective bargaining power typically results in more stable pricing than individual carrier relationships.

    Is MyParcel suitable for international shipping?

    Absolutely! MyParcel supports international shipping to over 200 countries through partnerships with DHL, DPD, and other international carriers. You get the same easy interface for both domestic and international shipments.

    How does MyParcel handle returns?

    MyParcel includes a built-in returns portal where customers can initiate returns themselves. You can customize the return policy, generate return labels automatically, and track returned items—all from one dashboard.

    Do I need technical knowledge to set up MyParcel?

    Not at all! MyParcel is designed to be user-friendly. Most eCommerce platforms (including Store.icu) offer one-click integration. If you can manage your online store, you can set up MyParcel.

    The Verdict: Which is Better for Small Businesses?

    For the vast majority of small businesses, MyParcel is the clear winner. Here’s why:

    ✅ Choose MyParcel if you:

    • Ship fewer than 10,000 packages per month
    • Want to reduce shipping costs without sacrificing quality
    • Value your time and want to automate shipping processes
    • Want to provide a professional customer experience
    • Need flexibility to scale up or down as your business grows
    • Want access to multiple carriers through one platform
    • Prefer transparent, predictable pricing

    ⚠️ Consider Traditional Shipping if you:

    • Ship extremely high volumes (10,000+ per month) with leverage to negotiate
    • Have very specialized shipping needs not covered by standard carriers
    • Already have favorable long-term contracts in place
    • Have dedicated logistics staff to manage complex carrier relationships

    Take Action: Start Saving on Shipping Today

    The shipping landscape has changed dramatically in recent years. What worked for small businesses five years ago may be costing you time and money today. Modern platforms like MyParcel exist specifically to level the playing field, giving small businesses access to the same tools and rates that large enterprises enjoy.

    The question isn’t whether you can afford to switch to MyParcel—it’s whether you can afford not to.

    Ready to Streamline Your Shipping?

    Join thousands of small businesses saving time and money with MyParcel.

    Get Started with MyParcel + Store.icu →


    Looking for an all-in-one eCommerce solution? Store.icu offers white-label eCommerce site building with native MyParcel integration, making it easy to launch and scale your online store with professional shipping built right in.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Sign up now or never!

    Stay up to date with all things eCommerce, announcements, and more.